Welcome to The Original Coney Island
Welcome to "The Original Coney Island," a beloved landmark in Tulsa for over 40 years. Nestled at 11332 E 21st St, this family-owned gem serves up mouthwatering coneys, the largest Frito pies, and comforting homemade chili. Guests rave about their delightful customer service and warm atmosphere, where the owner personally engages with diners. Patrons often return for the crowd-favorite three-way chili and the iconic coneys, made with care and quality ingredients. Whether you're a first-timer or a long-time local, The Original Coney Island promises a taste of nostalgia and community spirit that keeps everyone coming back for more.
- 11332 E 21st St B, Tulsa, OK 74129, United States Hotline: +1 918-438-3089
The Original Coney Island has etched its name in Tulsa’s culinary landscape with a legacy that's over 40 years strong. Nestled at 11332 E 21st St B, Tulsa, OK, this family-owned gem specializes in classic coney dogs and hearty chili dishes. With its charm woven into the fabric of the community, it’s no wonder many consider this spot a staple for comfort food.
As you step inside, you’re met with a warm and inviting atmosphere, where friendly faces greet you with genuine hospitality. Customers rave about the quick service, making it an ideal lunch destination for those on the go. But don't let the quick service fool you—the flavors are anything but rushed. Each dish is a testament to the restaurant’s commitment to quality and flavor.
- Signature Dishes: The menu boasts a variety of offerings that capture the heart of comfort food. The 1/2 Pint of Chili with Cheese is a must-try, featuring homemade chili that speaks of secret family recipes. At just $8.50, it’s perfect for a light meal or paired with the Regular Coney—a delightfully classic combination of mustard, chili, and onions for $2.75.
- Three-Way Spaghetti: Known as the largest small 3-way in Tulsa, this dish features spaghetti topped with homemade chili and an option for extra toppings, making it a favorite among locals.
- Frito Pies: The homemade chili paired with crunchy Fritos creates an unforgettable experience—those looking for comfort food will find it here.
Patrons express their love for the food through enthusiastic reviews. Customer Sophie Perez couldn’t get enough of her meal, exclaiming, “I had 3 but I devoured 2 of them already!” While Jimmie Wilkerson shares an impassioned account of the three-way chili, calling it “the best I have ever had.” Such comments highlight the restaurant's ability to foster a loyal customer base.
The Original Coney Island is not just about food; it’s about community and connection. The owner, often seen engaging with guests, adds a personal touch that enhances the dining experience. As Steve Cox put it, “Rowdy is always behind the counter and makes all the customers feel like family.” It’s this familial bond that keeps patrons returning time and again.
In conclusion, The Original Coney Island is more than just a restaurant; it's a cherished landmark where delicious food and community spirit collide. Whether it’s a quick lunch, a family outing, or a fulfilling meal after a long day, this spot will leave you satisfied and craving more. Don’t miss out on the best coneys in town—visit today and see for yourself why Tulsa loves this restaurant!
Contact:
Phone: +1 918-438-3089

I had 3 but I devoured 2 of them already! I absolutely love the atmosphere here! Always friendly and quick!

Great spot for lunch. Staff was very friendly. First time trying coneys and will definitely be back soon.

Omg the best I have been to. Best I have ever had. The owner is great. Talks with all of his guest. The coneys where great and omg the three way chilli is so far the best. I couldn't stop eating it. Been there for a long time. Family owned for 40 years.

Best coney(s) on the planet. If I had one last meal, this would be it.

Hadn't been there in years due to work schedule. Had a tooth extraction today and needed soft food. Today was a good day. Soft and Delicious! Thank you for the awesome Customer service

Great place for coneys. Friendly staff. Watch the cayenne pepper shaker! Those holes are big. You can make your coneys too hot quickly.

Family owned business thst has been in operation for YEARS. I've been going there for at least 15 years now. IMO the very best coneys anywhere. Rowdy is always behind the counter and makes all the customers feel like family. Do yourself a favor and try this place

Gus's has been a locally owned business in Tulsa for a VERY long time. Great food, great service and GREAT people. If you want some AWESOME authentic Coney's this is the place to go.