The Original Coney Island Menu (Update 2025)

  1. Home
  2. Menu

Welcome to The Original Coney Island, an iconic Tulsa eatery serving up classic American comfort food for over 40 years. Nestled at 11332 E 21st St B, this family-owned gem is renowned for its mouthwatering coneys and hearty chili dishes. The menu shines with options like the Regular Coney topped with mustard, chili, and onions, all for just $2.75, and the immense Large 3-Way Spaghetti, featuring spaghetti, chili, and your choice of toppings for $10.00.

Each dish is crafted with love, boasting homemade flavors that keep patrons coming back. The Cheese Coney and chili combinations are personal highlights, celebrated for their rich taste and generous servings. Guests rave about the friendly atmosphere—where owners join in the conversations, making it feel like home. If you’re seeking authentic coney delights, your search ends here!

Item

Item

Regular Coney

Mustard, chili and onions
$2.75

Cheese Coney

Mustard, chili, onions and cheese Shredded cheese or delicious squeeze cheese
$2.85

Relish Coney

Mustard, chili, onions and relish
$2.85

Cheese & Relish

Mustard, chili, onions, relish and cheese Shredded cheese or delicious squeeze cheese
$2.90

1/2 Pint Of Chili

Homemade chili. Add beans and onions. Comes with crackers
$7.50

1/2 Pint Of Chili With Cheese

Homemade chili with cheese. Add onions and or beans. Comes with crackers
$8.50

Large Frito Pie

LargestLarge Frito Pie in Tulsa. Fritos and delicious homemade chili. Add onions and or cheese
$10.00

Large Chili 3 Way Spaghetti

Largest Large 3-Way in Tulsa. Spaghetti, Chili, Beans. Add onions and or cheese. Comes with crackers
$10.00

Chips

We offer Nacho Cheese Doritos, Regular Lay's, Funyuns, BBQ Lay's, Regular Cheetos and Regular Fritos
$1.50

20 Oz. Pop

20 Oz. Cup, Ice and Pop. We offer Coke, Diet Coke, Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Mountain Dew, Root Beer and Dr. Pepper
$2.50

Plain Hot Dog

Add mustard or ketchup
$1.75

Pint Of Chili

Homemade Chili. Add Beans and or onions. Comes with crackers
$10.50

Pint Of Chili With Cheese

Homemade Chili with Cheese. Add Beans and or Onions. Comes with crackers
$11.50

Small Frito Pie

Largest Small Frito Pie in Tulsa. Homemade chili and Fritos. Add Onions and or Cheese
$8.00

Small 3-Way Spaghetti

Largest Small 3-Way in Tulsa. Homemade Chili and Spaghetti. Add Onions and or Cheese. Comes with crackers.
$8.00